Short answer: Below are 8 free SQE1 Tort practice questions with worked answers. Tort is tested in FLK1. Each question is in the SQE1 single best answer format: a scenario, five options and one correct answer. Try each one, then open “Show the answer” for the answer and the reasoning. You do not need an account.
The questions are copied word for word from the BAREX question bank and were checked against the law on 18 November 2026. For one question from every SQE1 subject, see our 29 free SQE1 practice questions with answers. For a full timed session, the free SQE1 mock exam has 85 questions in 2 hours 33 minutes.
How to use these questions
- Give yourself about 1 minute 48 seconds a question, the SQE1 pace.
- Pick your answer before you open the explanation, and note why you chose it.
- When you get one wrong, find the fact in the scenario that decided it.
SQE1 Tort practice questions
Question 1: Secondary victim control mechanisms
A group of office colleagues are in a pub after work, chatting casually while waiting for a train, and a live news broadcast on the television above the bar shows a bridge collapse that kills several named workers at a distant site. None of the colleagues knows any of the dead people personally, and none was present at the scene or the emergency response. The pub is crowded, and the image repeatedly cuts to distressed presenters describing the aftermath as some of the colleagues become visibly upset and remain watching for the next hour. They stay seated rather than leave, partly because other patrons are also watching and the footage keeps being replayed on the screen. On the way home, they discuss what they have seen, and the incident continues to trouble them afterward. Several later develop trauma symptoms and seek damages for psychiatric injury. Which statement best describes their claim?
Show the answer
The answer is B
Option B is correct. A secondary victim must satisfy all the control mechanisms: a close tie of love and affection with the primary victim, proximity in time and space, and perception of the accident or immediate aftermath with unaided senses. Here the colleagues did not know any of the dead workers, so the relationship requirement fails outright, and they watched a broadcast from a distant site, so they did not directly perceive the event. Their distress and trauma symptoms cannot substitute for these requirements. Option A fails because even a live broadcast does not automatically amount to direct perception, and in any event the claimants have no close tie to anyone shown. Option C fails because a recognised psychiatric illness is only a threshold condition, not a replacement for the other controls. Option D fails because it implies the claim would succeed if the broadcast were live; the absence of any tie of love and affection defeats the claim whatever the timing of the broadcast. Option E fails because English law has no free-standing horror principle; bystanders do not recover merely because the event was shocking.
Question 2: Pure economic loss
A small brewery stores beer in vats that are supplied by an external power feed. Contractors next door, working on a new loading bay, cut the wrong cable, and the power fails for a full day during a busy production run. One vat is ruined, and the brewery also says it would have produced three further vats during the shutdown. The brewery had customer orders ready and no replacement power was available. The brewery had arranged routine deliveries for that day, and managers spent the rest of the morning checking whether the production line could be restarted before the orders were cancelled. Staff also recorded the spoilage and the halted output for insurance and accounting purposes, but there was no suggestion that any other part of the site was damaged. Assuming negligence is otherwise established, which statement best describes the recoverable loss?
Show the answer
The answer is A
Option A is correct. Negligence can compensate the value of damaged property and financial loss consequential on that damage. It generally does not compensate trading profit lost merely because a utility interruption prevents production. Spartan Steel distinguishes those categories even where both arise from the same careless cable damage. The ruined vat represents damage to the brewery’s own property, so its value and associated lost profit are recoverable. The further three vats were never produced: their missing profit arises from inability to trade, without corresponding damage to those goods. Option B allows only that excluded trading loss while omitting the recoverable damaged-property loss. Option C wrongly treats foreseeability as sufficient to overcome the exclusion of pure economic loss. Option D assumes ownership of the cut cable is essential, although the brewery claims for its own spoiled property. Option E correctly excludes the further production profits but allows only profit on the ruined vat, wrongly omitting the value of the damaged goods themselves.
Question 3: Negligence, breach of duty
A small cricket ground stands next to a footpath, and local residents regularly use the path to reach nearby houses and shops. Over many seasons, only a handful of balls have ever left the ground, but on a windy afternoon one high shot clears the boundary and hits a pedestrian, causing a head injury. The club had already tried to reduce the risk by placing ordinary fencing around the outfield, and members had considered whether a more substantial barrier would help. They knew such a barrier would be costly and would interfere with play, and the club continued to use the ground in the same way. The question is whether, in those circumstances, the club failed to take reasonable care for people using the path. Which of the following statements best describes the breach question?
Show the answer
The answer is A
Option A is correct. Breach is decided by weighing the magnitude of the risk, that is the likelihood of harm and its seriousness, against the cost and practicality of further precautions (Bolton v Stone). Foreseeability of some harm is not enough where the chance is very small. Here only a handful of balls had ever left the ground over many seasons, the club already had ordinary fencing, and a more substantial barrier would have been costly and would have interfered with play. The real question is whether those factors justified further action, and A states exactly that. Option B is wrong because it imposes strict liability for any injury to a spectator or passer-by, whereas negligence requires a failure to take reasonable care. Option C is wrong because the test is reasonable foreseeability and proportionate precautions, and certainty of prediction is not required. Option D is wrong because the but for test belongs to factual causation, not breach. Option E is wrong because the club's lack of control over the weather is irrelevant to the standard of care; it is not a requirement for liability.
Question 4: Negligence, causation
A patient arrives at hospital after collapsing at home, with symptoms that are treated as an allergic reaction. The ambulance crew passes on a brief history from relatives, and the patient is triaged, examined, and moved to observation while staff focus on a possible allergic episode. A doctor gives standard medication and records the patient as stable, but the patient later dies despite close monitoring. The family later reviews the hospital notes and says the signs were obvious enough that a different diagnosis should have been made sooner. An autopsy shows the patient had swallowed a rare toxin for which no effective treatment existed, and the family says the wrong diagnosis caused the death. Hospital staff also document that they are continuing to search for an alternative cause, but nothing in the immediate treatment plan changes before the death. The dispute is whether the initial misdiagnosis made any legal difference. Which statement best describes the causation issue?
Show the answer
The answer is A
The correct answer is A. The key point is that a diagnostic mistake does not automatically make the hospital liable: the claimant must still prove causation on the balance of probabilities. If the patient would have died even with a correct diagnosis and appropriate treatment, the negligence is not the legal cause of death. On these facts, the autopsy showed a rare toxin had been swallowed and there was no effective treatment, so a correct diagnosis would not have changed the outcome. That means the claim fails on but-for causation. Option B is wrong because breach alone is not enough. Option C is wrong because the estate can bring a claim. Option D is irrelevant because consent is not the causation issue. Option E is also wrong because the eggshell skull rule does not help where the death would have happened anyway.
Question 5: Negligence, police duty of care
Police officers attended a rural road where black ice had already caused a crash after reports of difficult driving conditions from local motorists using the route. The road was unlit and normally used by people travelling between nearby villages, so the scene remained accessible to traffic while they were there. It was an ordinary journey for those using the road, and visibility was poor in the fading light. They placed a warning marker and then left after checking the road surface without arranging any further traffic control. A second vehicle later skidded at the same spot injuring several people. The claimants say the officers should have done more to protect motorists because the hazard remained obvious and dangerous. The client asks for immediate advice on the legal position in negligence. Which statement best reflects the law?
Show the answer
The answer is B
Option B is correct. Public authorities such as the police are generally under no common-law duty to protect people from a danger they did not create. A duty may arise only where the authority assumed responsibility, or where its own positive conduct created or worsened the danger or stopped others protecting themselves, the interference principle. Here the black ice was already present. The officers placed a warning marker, checked the surface and left, which neither created nor aggravated the hazard and did not displace anyone's own precautions. So no duty arose. Option A is wrong because awareness of a risk and the ability to remove it do not create a duty without a duty-creating feature. Option C is wrong because merely responding to a hazard does not create responsibility. Option D is wrong because it is too absolute: third-party or external danger does not always defeat negligence, and liability can arise where the authority makes matters worse or assumes responsibility. Option E is wrong because a minimal warning marker does not amount to an assumption of responsibility for road users' safety.
Question 6: Vicarious liability
A media company engages a technician under a written “independent contractor” agreement. She invoices for each completed project, supplies and maintains her own specialist equipment, and is free to accept work from other clients. The company nevertheless fixes project deadlines, requires her to use its reporting system, and expects her to attend planning meetings with its staff. The parties disagree whether the contractual label reflects the true relationship. The question concerns the historical approaches used to distinguish a contract of service from a contract for services, rather than the later scope question of an employee's tort. Which of the following statements best identifies the framework relevant to classifying this relationship?
Show the answer
The answer is C
Option C is correct. The historical approaches to distinguishing employment from independent contracting are the control test, the integration test, and the multiple, or economic-reality, test. Control considers the extent to which the engager directs the work; the deadlines, reporting requirements, and meetings here suggest some control. Integration asks whether the worker is part of the organisation or merely an accessory; the staff interaction points towards integration, while her other clients and own equipment point away from it. The multiple test weighs the relationship as a whole, including control, equipment, financial risk, opportunity for profit, and delegation, so no single factor is decisive. The contractual label is relevant but does not settle the issue. Option A is wrong because incorporation and compound are not the recognised historical tests, and the label is not conclusive. Option B includes integration but substitutes causation and proportionality concepts for the other status tests. Option D lists concepts concerning tort liability or policy, not employment classification. Option E replaces the multiple or economic-reality test with an unrecognised proportionate test.
Question 7: Private nuisance
A café in a mixed residential and commercial street has played amplified music every night for over twenty years, including through closed windows and after local closing time. The building is old and the street is busy during the day, but the buyer of the flat next door says the disturbance is worst at night when the area is otherwise quiet. The buyer says the noise is intolerable, has started keeping records of the disturbance, and seeks to stop it. The café owner argues that the long history of the music gives a complete defence, pointing out that the flat was purchased only recently and that no complaint was made by the former owner. The owner also says the music has always been an ordinary feature of the business. The client asks for immediate advice on the legal position. Which option best reflects the rule on prescription in private nuisance?
Show the answer
The answer is D
Option D is correct. Prescription is a defence to private nuisance only, and the defendant must show 20 years of uninterrupted nuisance enjoyed as of right, without force, secrecy or permission. The clock starts only when the activity first becomes an actionable nuisance against the relevant claimant's land use, not when the activity began, and there is no general defence of coming to the nuisance. Here the café's music has run for over twenty years, but the owner's argument that long history alone is a complete defence fails; he must show 20 years of actionable nuisance against the neighbouring flat's use. The recent purchase and the former owner's silence do not by themselves defeat or establish the defence. Option A is wrong because mere long establishment does not make a nuisance lawful. Option B is wrong because prescription is available in private nuisance and not in public nuisance, which reverses the rule. Option C is wrong because arriving later does not bar a claim, as there is no coming-to-the-nuisance defence. Option E is wrong because consent is not implied in nuisance; prescription works through 20 years as of right, not implied consent.
Question 8: Trespasser and obvious recreational risk
A university owned a disused boating pond on its grounds. The pond had been left unused for some time, and the area was not maintained for recreation. Access was blocked by a chain, and notices at the entrance said the water was closed to the public. Campus staff had treated the pond as out of bounds, with no arrangements for supervised use, and anyone approaching it would have seen that the site was not intended for leisure activities. A student climbed through a gap in the fence at night with friends, ignored the notices, and jumped from a jetty into very shallow water, breaking his neck. He argues that the university knew the pond was near a path used by students and should have done more to protect him. Which of the following best describes the university's likely position under the 1984 Act?
Show the answer
The answer is C
The correct answer is C. Under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, an occupier is liable only for risks arising from dangers due to the state of the premises, or from things done or omitted on them. It does not make an occupier responsible for a claimant’s own voluntary activity. Here, the student’s injury was caused by his decision to jump into very shallow water, despite the chain and warning notices. That makes the university’s position strong: it had taken steps to keep people out and to warn them of the danger. Option A is too broad because mere knowledge that students might come near the pond does not by itself create liability. Option B is also too strong because the measures taken were relevant. Option D is wrong because the student was not a visitor owed the full duty. Option E is wrong because the 1984 Act does not exclude night-time injuries.
Practise more Tort
On BAREX you can practise Tort topic by topic, choose easy, medium or hard questions, and sit timed FLK1 mock sessions. A free account includes one full mock session.
Questions checked against the law on 18 November 2026.